Development diary ·
Part 5 – The 'red' prototype
Part 5 of the Scrooge development diary: the first playable 'red' prototype, the doubts it raised and the Dickens quote that kept the project alive.

Every design diary has an entry where the dream meets the table. For Scrooge it was the first prototype — the “red” one.
The game’s co-founder and creative lead was, in the family’s own phrase, a Scrooge nerd. He looked to Dickens’s words for wisdom, advice and encouragement in moments of doubt, and one such moment came right after the family played that first prototype.
It began as a jolly occasion. For the first time, the dream was approaching reality. But it also brought the realisation that there was a lot of work ahead, and that creating a board game unlike any other was flipping hard.
“No space of regret can make amends for one life’s opportunity misused.” — Charles Dickens, A Christmas Carol
That line, spoken by Marley’s ghost, settled it. The family were not about to give up on their dream and live a miserly life of regret like Scrooge. By the time this entry was posted in 2017, the final prototype was on its way.
Reading it now
The red prototype matters because it was bad in useful ways. It proved the theme worked and that people enjoyed the world, while exposing the weak mechanics. Many published games are born from exactly this kind of disappointing first draft — what separates them is whether the designers keep going.
Originally posted with the tag #nohumbugshere.