Skip to content

London streets · Ghost cards · Gold coins

ScroogeThe Board Game & the Tabletop

Development diary ·

Part 6 – Back to basics. Board game design is hard

Part 6 of the Scrooge development diary: creative brain freeze, months away from the prototype, and the Christmas that brought Ghost Cards, Nightmares and Steal streets.

Engraved-style plate of a friendly ghost between chains of coins

“An idea, like a ghost, must be spoken to a little before it will explain itself.” — Charles Dickens, Dombey and Son

The family were delighted with their first prototype, but it did not take long to realise two things. First, designing a board game is hard. Second, the game was missing some pizzazz.

They were knocked back to reality, with what they called creative brain freeze.

Leaving the game alone

Instead of forcing it, they let the game sit for some months. It was only when the family gathered again the following Christmas that the spark was reignited. Several additions from that period became core to the finished product:

  • Ghost Cards in their final role as protection and power for the end game;
  • Nightmares, cards that carry moral lessons and financial value but block victory;
  • Steal streets, spaces that let players take ghost cards from rivals.

Together they created the immersive experience the family had been looking for.

Why the pause worked

Stepping away is an underrated design tool. Playtesters who know a game too well stop noticing its flaws; time restores fresh eyes. The Dickens quotation chosen for this entry says the same thing more elegantly: ideas need to be spoken to — tested, discussed, revisited — before they reveal what they are for.

Originally posted with the tags #hope #dreambig #trytrytry.